Identical Particles and the Exclusion Principle
No experiment can tell two electrons apart, and quantum mechanics turns this into a rule about the sign of the wave function under exchange. This unit follows that rule to the Pauli exclusion principle, the periodic table and the saw-tooth of the ionization energies, the Fermi gas of electrons in copper and in a white dwarf, and the Bose-Einstein condensate first made from rubidium atoms at 170 nanokelvin in June 1995. Two research spotlights show a Fermi gas that refuses to scatter light and a condensate that stores a pulse of light.
Every electron in the universe is exactly like every other one, with the same mass, the same charge, and the same spin, and no experiment has ever found a mark that tells two of them apart. Classical physics takes no notice of this sameness. Quantum mechanics cannot ignore it, because a theory without trajectories has no way of keeping track of which electron is which, and the wave function must be written in a way that never pretends to know. This unit follows that single requirement to the structure of the periodic table, the stiffness of a metal, the pressure that holds a dead star against its own gravity, and a new state of matter that was predicted in 1925 and first seen on a laboratory bench in 1995.
1 Identical particles
Two billiard balls from the same factory are identical in the everyday sense, yet a camera can follow each of them through a collision and say afterwards which is which. The particles of quantum mechanics offer no such help. Units 3 and 4 showed that an electron between two measurements has no path, only a wave function, and when the wave functions of two electrons overlap, the electron found at one detector cannot be traced back to one of the two sources. Particles that share every intrinsic property and therefore cannot be distinguished by any measurement are called identical particles, and the theory has to be built so that a label attached to one of them has no physical meaning.
Consider two such particles with coordinates \(x_1\) and \(x_2\) (in three dimensions these stand for the position and the spin orientation of each particle) and a two-particle wave function \(\psi(x_1, x_2)\), whose modulus squared is the probability density for finding one particle at \(x_1\) and the other at \(x_2\). The operator that swaps the two labels is the exchange operator, \begin{equation} \op{P}\,\psi(x_1, x_2) = \psi(x_2, x_1) . \label{eq:exchange} \end{equation} Applied twice, it gives back the original function, \(\op{P}^2 = 1\). An eigenfunction with eigenvalue \(\lambda\) therefore satisfies \(\lambda^2 = 1\), so the eigenvalues can only be \(+1\) and \(-1\), and the eigenfunctions are the functions that either stay the same or change sign when the labels are swapped. Both kinds respect the indistinguishability, because the probability density \(|\psi|^2\) is unchanged in either case. For identical particles there is a stronger statement, which says that every allowed wave function, not only an eigenfunction, must be of one of these two kinds. The swapped function describes the same physical situation, so it can differ from the original by at most a phase factor, \(\psi(x_2, x_1) = e^{i\alpha}\psi(x_1, x_2)\). Swapping back multiplies by the same factor again and must return the original function, so \(e^{2i\alpha} = 1\), which leaves only the two values \(e^{i\alpha} = \pm 1\). In two dimensions this last step fails, and particles with other phases, called anyons, exist in thin layers of matter, but that topic lies beyond the unit.
Which sign applies turns out to be a fixed property of each kind of particle, never a choice made by the experimenter, and this fact is stated as a postulate alongside the five of Unit 9.
The rule that decides which particle belongs to which family is the spin-statistics connection: particles with integer spin (\(0\), \(1\), \(2\), and so on, in units of \(\hbar\)) are bosons, and particles with half-integer spin (\(\tfrac12\), \(\tfrac32\), and so on) are fermions. Within non-relativistic quantum mechanics this is an observed fact. Markus Fierz (1912-2006) in 1939 and Wolfgang Pauli (1900-1958) in 1940 proved that it follows from the union of quantum mechanics with special relativity, a result known as the spin-statistics theorem, whose proof is far beyond this masterclass. Table 1 sorts the particles the earlier units have met. The electron, the proton, and the neutron have spin-1/2 and are fermions; the photon has spin 1 and is a boson.